Three upvotes?
Low criteria for best of, no?
Manual curation is the criteria. If you think something is best it’s enough for a topic.
If it’s problematic or low quality, we can discuss options. But manual curation and the feel of just talking about what interests a person immediately is the point of this place.
That being said, it seems like the original topic was deleted or something. I can’t read it… That’s certainly a problem but not the one I expected.
You should get people to make a copy of the comment in question in the body of the post.
While this was a fine comment I agree that maybe it wasn’t quite “Best of Lemmy”. That being said, the purpose of this sub was always just manually highlighting things people found high quality. I don’t think certain upvote counts were ever required.
The comment being replied to was great. The one you picked, not so much.